Objective: To establish and validate a kind of capillary gel electrophoresis(CGE) method which can quantitate the content of plasmid DNA isoforms,and explore its application. Methods: Firstly using the coated capillary,the plasmid DNA( p16E25) was separated by CGE method. Then the plasmid p16E25 was digested by restriction and nicking endonuclease respectively and separated by CGE to determine which migration peak was supercoiled closed circular( ccc),linear or open circular(oc) form. Secondly,CGE method for plasmid DNA isoforms separation was further optimized for fluorescent dyes and loading concentration and then validated for its the specificity,accuracy,linearity,precision,limit of detection( LOD) and limit of quantitation( LOQ). Finally,the method was used to detect the change of plasmid DNA isoforms after treatment for being kept at varied temperature,several freeze-thawed cycles and UV irradiation. Results: After optimization,the content percentage of plasmid DNA isoforms could be well quantitated by CGE method with LIF detector using following parameters, including coated capillary whose total length was 40 cm, the 30.2 cm effective length( inlet to window),loading the 4 ng·μL-1 of plasmid DNA at 4 ℃ with capillary temperature at 20 ℃,and injection at 4 s at 1 378.95 Pa. The established CGE method could accurately quantify the content percentage of three plasmid DNA isoforms( ccc, linear and oc isoforms) with good resolution. The method had good specificity asthere was no observed interference from substances which were often used as plasmid DNA excipients. Linear range of the method for each of plasmid isoforms was from 0.25 ng·μL-1 to 8 ng·μL-1. A good linearity was exhibited between content percentage and loading concentration of each isoform,and the correlation coefficient were 0.997 7,0.999 4 and 0.992 7 for linear,oc and ccc isoforms of plasmid DNA,respectively. Spiking 3%-50% of linear or oc isoform plasmid to the original plasmid,the content percentage of the linear or plasmid exhibited good linearity,and the correlation coefficients were 0.999 9 and 0.997 2,respectively. The linear isoform had good recovery ratio ranged from 104% to 120%,which was better than that of oc isoform,rangingfrom 68% to 94%. The repeatability was determined by detecting three concentrations of high,medium and low concentrations of plasmid DNA (4,2 and 0.5 ng·μL-1). The RSD of migration time and content percentage of ccc plasmid were 0.22%-0.54% and 0.38%-2.1%, respectively. The results indicated the method had a good intra-assay repeatability. The intermediate precision was also good. The RSD of migration time was 0.52%-1.1%,and the RSD of content percentage were 3.6% and 0.25% corresponding to the medium and high loading concentration of plasmid DNA,respectively. Precision was better when the concentrations were 2 ng·μL-1 and 4 ng·μL-1,respectively. After sensitivity validation,LOQ and LOD of the method were 0.5 and 0.25 ng·μL-1,respectively. Finally,after full validation,the established CGE method could be used for intended purpose. The method was used to determine the change of plasmid DNA isoforms under different conditions,such as storage temperature,freeze-thawed cycles and UV irradiation. The results showed that the content percentage of ccc plasmid DNA isoform was not affected by stored at -80 ℃ and -20 ℃ for one week. However,after stored at room temperature for one week,the content percentage of oc plasmid DNA increased from 1.39% to 4.16%. Plasmid isoforms alteration was not obviously observed after five freeze-thawed cycles, but the content percentage of oc plasmid DNA was increased from about 1.3% to 1.93% after seven freeze-thawed cycles. When the 1 mg·mL-1 plasmid was exposed to UV irradiation for 15 min to 3 h,the content percentage of ccc plasmid DNA was markedly decreased from 96.97% to 54.38% along with content percentage of linear and oc plasmid DNA significantly increased. Conclusion: The established capillary gel electrophoresis method is capable of well separating the ccc,linear and oc isoforms of plasmid DNA,with high resolution. The method can be used to accurately quantify the content of different isoforms in a plasmid DNA,and it could detect the change of plasmid DNA isoforms with high sensitivity. Therefore,it will be helpful for control of plasmid DNA purity.
ZHANG Li-xia, WU Xue-ling, CHEN Xue-qing, XU Ling-li, ZHAO Peng, MENG Shu-fang
. Development and validation of capillary gel electrophoresis method to quantitate the content of plasmid DNA isoforms used for lentivirus production*[J]. Chinese Journal of Pharmaceutical Analysis, 2021
, 41(7)
: 1189
-1202
.
DOI: 10.16155/j.0254-1793.2021.07.10
[1] 哈小琴,吴祖泽,张庆林,等. 质粒超螺旋比例对其细胞转染效率及表达的影响[J]. 生物技术通讯,2005(4):392
HA XQ,WU ZZ,ZHANG QL,et al.Effect of plasmid super helix ratio on cell transfection efficiency and expression[J]. Lett Biotechnol,2005(4):392
[2] WALTHER W,STEIN U,VOSS C,et al.Stability analysis for long-term storage of naked DNA:impact on nonviral in vivo gene transfer[J]. Anal Biochem,2003,318(2):230
[3] ESCOFFRE JM,NIKOLOVA B,MALLET L,et al.New insights in the gene electrotransfer process:evidence for the involvement of the plasmid DNA topology[J]. Curr Gene Ther,2012,12(5):417
[4] FDA. Guidance for Industry:Chemistry,Manufacturing,and Control (CMC) Information for Human Gene Therapy Investigational New Drug Applications( INDs)[EB/OL].[2020-01-31]. https://www. fda.gov/regulatory-information/search-fda-guidance-documents/ chemistry-manufacturing-and-control-cmc-information-human-gene-therapy-investigational-new-drug
[5] EMA. Quality,Preclinical and Clinical Aspects of Gene Therapy Medicinal Products[EB/OL].[2018-07-13]. https://www.ema. europa.eu/en/quality-preclinical-clinical-aspects-gene-therapy-medicinal-products
[6] FDA. Guidance for Industry:Considerations for Plasmid DNA Vaccines for Infectious Disease Indications[EB/OL].[2007-11]. https://www.fda.gov/regulatory-information/search-fda-guidance-documents/considerations-plasmid-dna-vaccines-infectious-disease-indications
[7] MOLLOY MJ,HALL VS,BAILEY SI,et al.Effective and robust plasmid topology analysis and the subsequent characterization of the plasmid isoforms thereby observed[J]. Nucleic Acids Res,2004, 32(16):e129
[8] QUAAK SG,NUIJEN B,HAANEN JB,et al.Development and validation of an anion-exchange LC-UV method for the quantification and purity determination of the DNA plasmid pDERMATT[J]. J Pharm Biomed Anal,2009,49(2):282
[9] SMITH CR,DEPRINCE RB,DACKOR J.Separation of topological forms of plasmid DNA by anion-exchange HPLC:shifts in elution order of linear DNA[J]. J Chromatogr B Analyt Technol Biomed Life Sci,2007,854(1-2):121
[10] MAHUT M,GARGANO A,SCHUCHNIGG H,et al.Chemoaffinity material for plasmid DNA analysis by high-performance liquid chromatography with condition-dependent switching between isoform and topoisomer selectivity[J]. Anal Chem,2013,85(5):2913
[11] NACKERDIEN Z,MORRIS S,CHOQUETTE S,et al.Analysis of laser-induced plasmic DNA photolysis by capillary electrophoresis[J]. J Chromatogr B Biomed Appl,1996,683(1):91
[12] SCHMIDT T,FRIEHS K,SCHLEEF M,et al.Quantitative analysis of plasmid forms by agarose and capillary gel electrophoresis[J]. Anal Biochem,1999,274(2):235
[13] SCHLEEF M,SCHMIDT T.Animal-free production of ccc-supercoiled plasmids for research and clinical applications[J]. J Gene Med,2004,6:S45
[14] COOK KS,LUO J,GUTTMAN A,et al.Vaccine plasmid topology monitoring by capillary gel electrophoresis[J]. Curr Mol Med, 2020,20(10):798
[15] USP42-NF 37[S]. 2019:1047
[16] XIE TD,TSONG TY.Study of mechanisms of electric field-induced DNA transfection. V. effects of DNA topology on surface binding, cell uptake,expression,and integration into host chromosomes of DNA in the mammalian cell[J]. Biophys J,1993,65(4):1684
[17] CHERNG JY,SCHUURMANS-NIEUWENBROEK NM,JISKOOT W,et al.Effect of DNA topology on the transfection efficiency of poly ((2-dimethylamino)ethyl methacrylate)-plasmid complexes[J]. J Control Release,1999,60(2-3):343
[18] WALTHER W,SCHMEER M,KOBELT D,et al.A seven-year storage report of good manufacturing practice-grade naked plasmid DNA:stability,topology,and in vitro/in vivo functional analysis[J]. Hum Gene Ther Clin Dev,2013,24(4):147
[19] HOLOVICS HJ,HE Y,LACHER NA,et al.Capillary gel electrophoresis with laser-induced fluorescence of plasmid DNA in untreated capillary[J]. Electrophoresis,2010,31(14):2436
[20] DANG F,LI W,ZHANG L,et al.Electrophoretic behavior of plasmid DNA in the presence of various intercalating dyes[J]. J Chromatogr A,2006,1118(2):218